Serendipity - Version Bravo

by Lubrican

Chapters : 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | Epilogue

Chapter Nine

We had two more hours to settle down before the other two musketeers showed up. Even so, the change that had taken place was so big, or fundamental or whatever, that they sensed a difference almost right away. At least when it came to Kat. The girls stopped to give me a quick hug and kiss and then,apparently sensing nothing from me, went into the kitchen where Kat was making chocolate chip cookies.

"What happened to you?" I heard Ashley ask. I went to stand in the doorway and watch.

"What do you mean?" asked Caitlin.

"You look ... happy."

"Why wouldn't I be happy?" asked Caitlin.

"Happier than normal," said Ashley.

"So I'm happy. What's the big deal?"

Suddenly Caitlin wasn't so happy.

"Don't get freaked out," said Ashley. "All I said was that you looked happy."

"You two going swimming today?" I asked, trying to give Kat some relief.

"Do you want us to?" asked Emma, obviously fishing for a compliment.

"If you mean, do I want to see you naked, and play games and all that, then the answer is definitely yes," I said.

Emma beamed, and turned to Ashley.

"Can you believe he said that? Can you believe how much things have changed in just a week? This is freaking me out!"

"I don't want to freak you out," I said, holding out my hands, palms facing the girls.

"I didn't mean it in a bad way," said Emma. "I like what we've been doing. I love what we've been doing."

"Don't turn into a slut," cautioned Ashley.

"Like you?" quipped Emma.

"Help me with the cookies," said Caitlin, breaking up the joshing.

"I'll be in my office, trying to work," I said, and waved as I left.

I got the computer booted, and was about to open a project file when I sensed someone at the door. It was Ashley.

"Can I talk to you?" she asked.

"Of course. Come in."

She did more than that. She turned my desk chair, which has no arms on it, and straddled me, sitting on my lap. It made her head a little higher than mine, and put her nipples where, had they been naked, it would have been easy to lean forward and taste them.

"I need to ask you a question," she said, quietly.


She stared right into my eyes as she opened her mouth to speak, but then her eyes darted sideways before coming back to mine.

"Do you really want to fuck us?"

A lot flew through my mind at that moment. And it was complicated. But I could tell she wasn't in the mood for a complicated answer.

"Part of me would like that very much," I said. "Another part of me thinks that might be a bad idea."


"Which part?" I asked.

"Why does part of you not want to?"

"Well, history suggests that three women trying to share a man don't get along all that well," I said. "Then there's the part about you being so young. And it needs to be mentioned that any man would have a hard time satisfying three healthy young women."

"But you want to," she said. "Really, I mean. You're not just saying you do to make us feel good."

"Does it make you feel good?" I asked. "Because there are a lot of women out there who would be disgusted if they found out I felt that way about them."

"I'm not disgusted," she said.

"That's good ... I guess," I said.

"It makes me feel ... crazy."


"Yes. It makes me want to lose control."

"Well ... I guess it's good that you're figuring that out now, instead of in a car somewhere some evening in the future."

"We aren't going to do that," she said, firmly. "Okay. Good. Thank you."

She punctuated that "Thank you" with a kiss that made her squirm on my lap. Then she got up and left the room.

"Huddle in Kat's room," I heard her say.

"The timer says three more minutes," said Kat.

"Well, hurry up," said Ashley.

Ashley's visit to me set off some kind of alarm, or sensor or something. I can't explain it. What I can tell you is that I eavesdropped on the huddle, when it finally took place. They spoke around mouthfuls of warm cookie, but I still heard most of it. I got there a little late, because I figured if I let them get started, they might not notice any sounds I made as I eased toward the door. It was closed, but it was a hollow core door, so I could hear through it if I pressed my ear right against it. The first voice I heard was Emma's.

"But we agreed it would be next year!"

"I know," said Ashley. "But this is driving me crazy. I want to do it now."

"I have to leave in three days," said Caitlin.

"I know!" exploded Ashley. "That's the whole point. In three days we won't be able to do it, and I'll go insane!"

"I'm not ready," said Emma.

"Yes you are," argued Ashley. "You drool when he plays with you."

Had I not known about the pact already, I'd have been confused.

But I did know about the pact. And they were obviously negotiating a change to the agreement. I wondered what Kat was thinking. I also wondered what she looked like. I had a sudden fantasy in which I was on top of her, sliding into her, and she was trying to pretend it was the first time. Her dialogue, in my fantasy, was canned and defied belief.

"Just because I love his finger in me doesn't mean I'm ready to go all the way," said Emma. "Besides. He wouldn't do it, even if we asked him to."

"Yes he would," said Ashley. "If we asked him the right way, he would. I know he would."

"How?" asked two voices.

"Because he told me he wanted to," she said. "I talked to him a little while ago, in his office. He admitted he wants to do it with us. He might resist a little bit, but if we do it right, I think we can overwhelm him."

Did I mention that everything had changed?

I listened to our little, local Mata Hari scheme to try to bring to fruition their truly insane pact. I got it, on the level that it's understandable that three pubescent girls might cook up a fantasy like that, involving the only adult male that they perceived as a sexual role model.

But that was the fantasy of some fourteen year old girls. These girls weren't fourteen any more. And while they had not yet been afforded the title of adulthood, they were certainly old enough to recognize that childhood fantasies needed to be let go of at some point.

Like now?!

Granted, I had tagged one of the musketeers, and that had worked out swimmingly. Caitlin was happy, and I was happy. Our future together was foggy, but I knew there would be a future for us, somehow, some time, some way.

And, while I was sure Caitlin and I had a future together, I was pretty sure that said future probably didn't involve my penis going into either Ashley or Emma, whether they were "ready" or not.

So I did the adult thing.

I opened the door and walked into the huddle.

"Sorry to intrude," I said, "but I couldn't help overhearing your conversation."

"What?" Ashley looked a little pale. "How?" Her voice sounded a little pale too.

"I had my ear up against the door," I admitted.

"You spied on us?" Now Ashley sounded indignant.

"I listened to you, as you started planning my seduction," I corrected.

"Shit," said Ashley under her breath.

"Look, ladies," I said. "I'm flattered that you feel the way you do. I'm even honored. All three of you are women that any man would be proud to have on his arm. But-"

I was interrupted by Caitlin, who spoke frantically and firmly at the same time.

"We did it!" she blurted. "We did it last night. We did it three times. Four times. I can't remember how many times, but we did it and it was fantastic and I'm so sorry, but I couldn't resist."

And, of course, she started crying.

Well, that fucked up things good and proper, let me tell you. My not-so-carefully planned speech about responsibility and self control never got past my lips. Meanwhile Ashley and Emma went through various stages that included empathy for their crying friend, which involved hugging her, and anger at the same friend for violating the terms of the contract they had so foolishly made. Then there was curiosity about what that violation had been like. They wanted to ask her for the details, but there was an interloper in the room.

That would be me, of course.

As is so often the case, the sexual object of their desire was, at the moment, completely unwelcome to observe the feminine rituals being engaged in. This led to tension, since it was my house, and I wasn't going anywhere. While my own plan was a bust, I didn't feel like leaving my woman in the clutches of two others who might, out of some misguided desire to influence her, try to force a wedge into our brand new relationship.

"Can you go somewhere else?" asked Ashley, finally.

"No," I said. "I was involved. I should be here."

And so it was that I became the elephant in the room, while the three of them engaged in a huddle, like they'd done countless times before. Except it wasn't a typical huddle. One or the other of them kept glancing at the elephant as they talked. I must confess that I was a little shell shocked myself. After all, she'd insisted they could not find out about us, and yet she had fairly yelled it from the rooftop. So I'll just give you some of what I remember being said. You'll have to figure out who said what yourself, because I don't remember.

"You didn't!"

"Yes, I did!" (sobs)

"We weren't supposed to!"

"I knooooow."

"But you did it? You really did it?"


"More than once? Didn't you say four times or something?" (glance at me)

"Let me think. At bedtime. Then when we woke up."

"You slept with him?" (gasp and glance at me)

"Yes, it was so good to be there all night."

"And he jumped your bones?" (glance at me)

"No. It was more like I jumped his bones."

"Go on."

"Well ... we took a shower, and did it again."

"That's three." (glance at me)

"And then I got on top again."

"Again?! You got on top of him?"

"Yes. I sort of tricked him the first time. I was rubbing all over it, and then I just reached for it and put it in me. There wasn't anything he could do. I was too heavy for him to push off."

"He tried to push you off?" (glance at me)

"Only for a second. I can't remember too well. I think I was a little crazy. What I do remember is feeling something make a ball of warmth in me. It was so fantastic. I came so hard I almost passed out."

"But you weren't on top every time."

"No. Sometimes he was on top of me. It was crazy, because I was trapped ... I couldn't move, but I didn't care, because what he was doing felt so good I thought for sure I was going to break into tiny pieces and float away."

(three glances at me)


"What was it like to put on the condom? Was it hard?"

"Um ... I sort of forgot the condom."

"He got in you ... bareback?" (horrified gasp and two glances at me as I contemplated the fact that they knew that word, and used it so casually)

"It was amazing. It felt so good. I can't describe it. You guys have to try it."


"I'm serious. I can't wait to go again. You have to try it. You'll love it."

"This is all messed up. We were supposed to wait."

"I couldn't. I'm sorry."

"I don't want to wait either, even though I'm furious at him right now." (dark glance at me)

"I told you I'm not ready, yet."

"Then don't do it!"

"But that's not fair. If the two of you do it, I have to do it too!"

"No you don't."

"Yes I do!"

"Then get used to it, because I already told you I'm going crazy. Kat understands."

Suddenly, Ashley wasn't mad at Caitlin any more, for violating the agreement. That gave her the perfect excuse to violate it too. And if Emma wanted to drag herself, kicking and screaming, along for the ride, then that was acceptable too.

I finally spoke. "Don't I have some say in this matter?"

Ashley turned her full wrath on me.

"No! You fucked her!"

"We made love," I corrected.

She turned back to Caitlin, who had stopped crying.

"Is that true? Was he gentle and all that?"

"Yes. No. I don't know. Sometimes. The last time for sure. Once I was afraid he would eat me or something. But even then I wanted it to never stop. It was incredible ."

It was suddenly quiet, as the girls reflected on everything. Again, it was Ashley who broke the silence.

"So ... are we agreed? The schedule is moved up?"

"Wait a minute," I said. "You can't just do this."

"Why not?" asked Ashley. "You want to. You told me so. If you want to do it and we want to do it, what's the problem?"

"The problem is that it's an insane idea," I said. "Come on. The three of you? With just me? Let's not even mention the fact that I'm old enough to be your father."

"No you're not. My dad is forty-five."

"Almost old enough to be your father," I groaned. "But that's not the point. The point is that it isn't done this way. Three women don't share the same man. It just isn't done."

"Why not? We don't mind."

"How do you know?" I asked. "Sure, it's all just fun and games now. But what happens if somebody begins to develop feelings? You don't do this kind of thing on a lark, just for fun. At least I don't. I have to like the woman before I'll take things that far. I don't just get my balls off in some woman because she's handy."

"You don't like us?" Emma's voice was tragic.

"Of course I like you!" I barked. "That's the problem. I know myself. If I do this with any of you, I'm going to have real, intense, passionate feelings for you. How's that going to work? I can't fall in love with three women at the same time. It's not fucking allowed!"

"Who said anything about falling in love?" asked Ashley. "We just want to find out what it's like, and we chose you to do that with. What's the big deal?"

I tried to calm down.

"The big deal is that this is more serious than you understand." I turned to Caitlin. "Tell them."

"Tell us what?" asked Ashley.

Caitlin looked uncomfortable. I remembered this was all new to her.

"Okay, let me tell them," I said. "It's like this. Yes, we made love. We didn't fuck. We made love." I thought about how little choice Caitlin had had about that a couple of times. I'd been pretty fired up. An argument could be made that I had 'fucked' her at least once. "Okay, most of the time we made love," I amended. "The point is that what I feel for Caitlin isn't good, because I want to be with her all the time. I want her to come live with me, like a wife. And yes, I know that's crazy, but that's the kind of passion this sort of thing can generate. And now you want to do the same thing. What happens if I fall in love with you, or you fall in love with me? I'm not a Mormon. I can't have three wives."

I admit I used a little hyperbole in there, talking about falling in love during one act of coitus, and about the Mormon business and all that, but I was trying to make a point. It really was crazy for them to think that using me like that would be without emotional consequences.

Such as it turning into a situation where I was using them.

Because while I was trying to talk them out of all this ... my dick was as hard as it had ever been in my life.

Now I know I was sending mixed signals. What I'd said about Caitlin and me was true. I did want to be with her on a more or less permanent basis. I knew that was not workable, but that didn't affect what I wished could happen. And I think it was the way I felt about her that made me reluctant to do anything with the other two. I mean ... it would feel like cheating on Caitlin ... right?

In fact, it already felt like I was cheating on her, because what man doesn't like the idea of having his own little harem?

But that was crazy too. Unworkable in every way imaginable. What man really can satisfy three women? What three women would consent to share the same man? And then there was the age difference. And the fact that I'd be taking Caitlin home in just a few, short days. If we did that, what did it mean for the other two, while Caitlin was home? And they were all going to graduate and scatter to the winds.

It was just not a good idea.

But what teenager has ever just accepted the advice of an adult, when said teenager already had "things figured out"?

"We don't want to marry you, Mister Ess," said Ashley, softly. "We just want to have sex. Just once. Like you and Kat did."

"You have no concept of what Kat and I did," I said.

"Okay, that's true. But people do this all the time. It can't be that big of a deal!"

I froze. She just didn't get it. She couldn't get it. She'd never be able to understand until she went through it.

I looked at Ashley. She was a typical teenage girl in most ways. I liked her. She was intelligent. She had a good sense of humor. She was a little pushy at times, but then aren't most women? She was a hottie. I had to admit that. And I'd fantasized about her long before she got naked in front of me, or we did anything at all. She loved to suck cock. And I loved to have my cock sucked.

Most of all ... she was willing. She wanted me!

"Just once," I said. It just came out.

"Of course," she said, a little flippantly. She turned a knowing grin on her cohorts. She'd been sure she'd get her way the whole time.

And that was when I decided I was going to rock Ashley Paddington's life. They say a woman never forgets her first time. Well, I was going to make sure of that.

And I knew that the next man she let between her legs would probably be a fumbling little boy. Most young men are. I was going to make sure Ashley Paddington knew the difference ... and would never be satisfied with a man like that for the rest of her life.

Youth is impatient. Once the deal was struck, Ashley wanted to plow on ahead and get things done.

"Not so quick," I said, when she suggested that we go to my bedroom and do the deed immediately. "I know you just want to have sex, but that's not how I roll." I felt stupid immediately for using that phrase. It didn't seem to bother her, though. "If we're going to do this, we're going to do it right. And that takes time."

"How much time?" she asked.

I looked at Kat, who looked a little pensive.

"Caitlin and I spent six hours together."

"But it won't take that long," she argued. "All I want to do is find out what it's like."

"And I'm going to show you what it's like," I said, smoothly. "But what you're trying to do is take one bite, to find out what a seven course meal tastes like."

"I don't want a seven course meal," she moaned. "I just want to have sex."

"We're going to do it my way, or not at all," I finally said, putting my foot down.

"Okay, okay," she caved. "But I don't have six hours. I have to be home for supper. My aunt and uncle are coming to visit."

"Then perhaps there could be a final sleepover," I suggested. "Before Caitlin leaves."

"Of course!" Ashley yipped. "That's perfect! We can stay all night!"

"I don't think I'm ready for this," said Emma, sounding scared.

I stepped toward her and she actually flinched away from me. When I held out my hand, though, she took it. I pulled her off the bed, where she'd been sitting, Indian style, and put my arms around her in a gentle hug.

"I'll never hurt you or do anything to you that you're not sure you want to do," I said into her hair.

"Okay," she said, and I felt her relax.

"We all have to do this," said Ashley, getting pushy.

"No ... you don't," I said firmly. "I know you three have a past, and a pact and all that crap, but you've grown up. You're going to leave Never Never Land and go back to school and graduate and be adults, and while I hope you remain friends for the rest of your lives, you aren't going to do everything together. And we're going to start that right now. If Emma doesn't want to have sex, then Emma doesn't have to have sex."

"I want to," said Emma, destroying my speech. "I'm just scared, that's all. I'm just not sure I'm ready."

"Well, you don't have to do anything just because of some stupid pact, okay?"

"It wasn't a stupid pact," said Ashley, sounding angry.

"I'm sorry," I said. "You're right. It was something serious to the three of you, but you understand we can't make Emma do something like that. It would be rape."

"I get that," said Ashley, but she still sounded aggrieved.

"Okay, then," I said. "I'll leave the three of you to your machinations. I'm sorry I spied on you and intruded. I just felt like things needed to get clarified."

"No problem. We're going swimming later. See you then."

It wasn't until I closed the door and started back toward my office that I realized "clarifying" things had ended up with the situation being exactly as it had been before I went into the room to disrupt their nefarious plan.

The plan had been for me to deflower them at the agreed upon time.

And now the time had been agreed upon.

I hadn't stopped anything.

<< Previous Chapter | Next Chapter >>